Home Australia Amazon, Bitcoin, Corruptocrats, Driving Events, Fake-news, the Gardener and Harvey (A morsel...

Amazon, Bitcoin, Corruptocrats, Driving Events, Fake-news, the Gardener and Harvey (A morsel from 2017)

Saeed Noori in a white SUV about to collect the man with an orange shirt, 21 December 2017. You can always rely on Channel 7 to disclose the footage (as they did with the Bryant interviews). But why is the CCTV footage 2 hours out? (Fix the cameras. It should read 16:40:01)

by Dee McLachlan

2017 was the year that I started the series on ‘Humanity in Crisis,’ covering: Government Secrecy, What the Money Printers Are Really Doing, The Food Controllers, Trashing Our Planet, The Radiation from Fukushima, Weapons of Mass Insanity, Mass Extinction, and Missing Shoals and the Blob. But there is so much more to write about.

Gumshoe kept up its older themes too, such as 9-11, Port Arthur, vaccination, loss of civil liberties, and Syria. This article covers a few A, B, C… topics that cropped up this year — topics that might have further traction in 2018. So here goes…

2017 — The Year of “Fake News”

I flicked onto the ABC about a week ago, and they were doing a wrap up of 2017 — announcing that ‘a’ Wooden Spoon Award for 2017 goes to the  “Alternative News.”  Amazing. 2017 proved to be the year the mainstream media’s cries of “fake news” stunningly boomeranged back into them.

Facebook has its own version of the “truth”

Over the decades the MSM have become more and more fake — so much so, that they are still unable to report what really happened on November 22, 1963 at 12:30pm in Dallas — for example. John F Kennedy was assassinated over 50 years ago, yet they are still propagating the most outrageous theory.

And the MSM remain hypnotized by the collapses of the twin towers, and still haven’t been able to tackle Building 7.

I wrote a public letter to Rupert Murdoch nearly three years ago, called “Rupert Murdoch – This Could Be Your Greatest Hour.” This is what I wrote back then:

“Mr Murdoch we are DROWNING in political lies and deception – and YOU have the power, the influence, and the reach to change this world forever…

“You could forward a brief to all your editors, CEOs and managers… [and instruct them to investigate] the evidence and facts surrounding past and future terror events, wars, banking and politics. Disclose the real news, without fear or favour.”

Murdoch and News Corp will eventually follow the dinosaurs into extinction if they continue to believe in their own fake news. 

Sex, Lies and Videotape

Now let’s get to Harvey and the sequellae of that.

The back of Harvey Weinstein

In 1989, Harvey Weinstein released Steven Soderbergh’s Sex, Lies, and Videotape, which propelled his company, Miramax, to become the most successful independent studio in America. He soon rose to God-like status in the entertainment business — protected by the industry and the press. But in October 2017, the NYT published the sexual assault claims from actors Ashley Judd and Rose McGowan. Since then, more than 90 women have come forward. Hundreds of people knew of his behaviour, but kept silent.

The dominoes started falling.

What’s in Burke’s Backyard?

ABC should give its “wooden spoon” award to TV’s gardening celebrity Don Burke, for coming up with the most crazy excuse for his inappropriate behaviour towards women.

Don Burke

The gardening celeb blamed his behaviour on self-diagnosed Aspergers, and in an interview with Tracy Grimshaw, he said:

“I can look at a lens but I have difficulty looking at people in the eye. I missed the body language and the subtle signs that people give you… [etc]”

I was chatting to a woman a few years older than Burke about it. She said, “My past husbands must have had Aspergers,” then added, “Macho society embolden some men to behave that way, and if they didn’t, they were often called pooftas.”

The MSM also reported on a past culture amongst Victoria Police that makes the celebrity gardener look like a lily in comparison. The culture of sexual discrimination, and predatory behaviour among the police was egregious.

Still, only the tip of the iceberg has been viewed. Actor Corey Feldman has been vocal for many years about pedophilia in Hollywood, and says many of the people who abused him and fellow child actor Corey Haim — who died in 2010 — are still around.

The ice has cracked, so maybe we will see more uncovered in 2018. Society has had the hors d’oeuvres served up, and are ready for the pizza entrée.

The Big A’s in Australia

2018 will be a year global giants consolidate their turf in Australia.

Proposed Apple store

It seems Apple has had the go-ahead to build one of their mega-stores at the iconic Federation Square in Melbourne — right opposite Gargasoulas’s “donut” intersection.

This comment, and many like this, appeared in The Herald Sun:

“Rather than offer Apple pride of place in Fed Square, it’s more to the point for it to pay more tax on its vast sales in Australia.” Tony Adami

2017 was the year Amazon moved into Australia, and is also when its founder, Jeff Bezos, become the 100 billion-dollar-man. More than half the countries on the globe have GDPs less than $100,000,000,000 a year (short scale billion, I presume).

At the same time the Sunday Mirror had a journalist working uncover in the UK, at the giant’s newest warehouse in Essex — earning about $11.50 per hour. The journalist wrote:

“I saw staff struggling to meet impossible targets, in constant fear of the sack… At every turn it felt like the human staff were reduced to livestock, existing only to service the machines…”

Amazon is clearly committed to a future with less and less human workers as robots take their place in “humanity’s progress“.

2017 — The Year of Driving into Pedestrians

(photo – news.com.au)

A week ago we had ANOTHER mentally unstable man drive into pedestrians on Flinders Street, in Melbourne. This is the third incident in the area, and 20 people were injured — one person is still in critical condition. The alleged ice addict Saeed Noori was charged with 18 counts of ­attempted murder.

This event needs more investigation. But why do the CCTV cameras indicate the rampage at 1440 hours, when it was reported at 4.40pm (1640 hours). And I quote the Herald Sun:

“Within 15 seconds, members of the Victoria Police’s critical incident response team are there…” [very speedy indeed]

But talking about robots; in my article “Vehicular Weapons“, I wrote:

“What are the authorities going to do? Bring in driver-less cars as soon as possible? What legislation and restrictions can we expect in the near future… “to keep us safe”?

As we drove into the country for a family Christmas eve dinner this year, we were discussing the future of driver-less cars. My son explained that driver-less cars will act like a centipede. For example, in the future, when cars take off from a set of lights, they will take off together — in ‘unison’.

In fact the traffic experience will be completely different, and if you have one human driver in the mix, the system just won’t work properly. He predicts that driver-less zones — starting in city centers — will be implemented in the near future. In these zones there will be no speeding, no drunken drivers, no terrorist drivers, and no fines. And soon, kids will no longer learn how to drive.

Perhaps my analysis of the “run over pedestrian” phase will in fact be a justification for this new “technological advance”. It also propped up the fad of putting bollards around valuable cultural entities. What are we coming to?

2017 — The Year of the Bitcoin

2017 saw the dramatic rise of Bitcoin, and the first Bitcoin billionaires.

Natural News predicts that 2018 will be the year that central banks begin to fight back against the growing phenomenon of cryptocurrency — as manipulating the crypto markets will be easy.

Mike Adams writes that the “establishment” isn’t anti-crypto, they’re just “anti” anything they don’t control — and that linking a major terrorism event (or false flag event) to Bitcoin will be a way to start the process of criminalizing Bitcoin.

2017 — The Australian Swamp

2017 was the year that the Australian people woke up to the idea that there is a swamp not only in Washington, DC, but in Canberra.

More people realize that the politicians are in for themselves — like Andrew Robb’s “consulting fee” of $880,000 each year, for NO consulting obligations. This has become the norm. The treasurer, Scott Morrison, in a speech to the Liberal party’s federal council in Sydney, said Australians had “collectively reached for the remote and turned down the volume on Canberra’s noise.”

Barnaby and Gina

More trough feeding was on display when mining and cattle baron Gina Rinehart presented Barnaby Joyce a $40,000 prize/gift at a glitzy agriculture event put on by her company Hancock Prospecting. Although Joyce initially accepted the giant novelty cheque, he handed it back after a backlash from the public.

The most disgraceful news at Canberra was the building of the FENCE. It demonstrates clearly the mentality of those leading us. They are a bunch of cowards out of touch with the people – whom they consider “stupid and wrong”. (That quote was said in parliament — aimed at anyone who does not believe the official 9-11 fairy tale.)

Here’s the real question: Are Federal politicians prisoners of the global cabal? Can they speak freely? I believe not. The ongoing suppression of the Port Arthur reality is a demonstration of their bondage and committal.

And the fence is symbolic of our present Australian attitudes (in more ways than one).

Thank-you’s from Gumshoe

I heartily thank regular “legal” contributors James O’Neill, and of course Mary Maxwell. (Mary has done a separate wrap-up.) I am indebted to Greg Buck for videos on economics, and for “guest writers” — Phil Hingston, Cathy Jamieson, Greg Maybury, Cesar Baruja, MD, Alan Cantwell, MD, and others. A special thanks to G5 for trusting Gumshoe to put out information. There were also persons whose essays we simply lifted, such as Rev Kevin Annett and Dutch journalist Karel van Wolferen. Several persons sent me leads to key publications. Thank you!

I THANK Gumshoe’s financial contributors — and for the gold bottle cap. And our wonderful commenters are indispensable. I am grateful to those who re-blogged us, including Cairns News and Tim Veater, and to Ian Cognito who made the photoshop production of Trump and Stalin on Boston’s Boylston St.

Again I declare my appreciation for the readers who answered the survey and thus helped me redesign the website.  I thank Jon Faine for providing, well, a perfect target.

For this annual wrap-up, I would be pleased if you would note in the Comments today, any special favorite item you recall from this year’s Gumshoe offerings — or topics to cover.

Please help us to get a wider audience!

And now for George Carlin.




  1. For the majority , Australian property is Australian poverty ….. the banksters crimes of the centuries .

    This morning , drove past a construction site , new immigrants assembling stick sheds that will be sold as million dollar plus housing .Seriously folks , in Bangla Desh they build better and more solid structures . With interest over thirty years , that’s $2.5 million for a shed that cost 100 – 200k to build .

    The sheeple have been fleeced and the wool has stopped growing on Australia’s back .
    That’s why most of our “leaders” have that stupid grin of arrogance .

    • And that “million dollar plus housing” = preposterous “rental value”= more taxation,more lucre for the planets parasites & leeches.

      Took me a while to figure out why building inspectors were passing anything &everything: in an Age of refined technological know-how people living in grossly energy inefficient dwellings that are totally vulnerable to such forces as flood, fire, and even high wind

      • On top of the housing rip off, there is a tiny fact, that many Australians are totally oblivious of, and that is despite going into hock to the banks for our entire lifetimes to buy a home, it is FACT, despite paying an exhorbitant amount for the land to build these rip offs on, you NEVER own that land, ever. Basicly, all that your doing is paying rent on the land to use it, you NEVER own it, the Government can, at any time it chooses, reclaim that land whenever it feels like it, and pay you a compensation fee that barely ever covers the costs required to buy another and move.
        If the Government receives a mining exploratory submission and your house is standing on said land included in that submission, you have no right whatever to prevent said mining company coming in and digging up your garden. As the pastoralists anywhere in Australia, what their rights are, when it comes to mining, home owners are no different.
        As far as I’m aware, Australia is one of the few countries with such laws.
        So what exactly are we buying, when we buy a block of land to build our shonky homes upon ???????????

          • Great country even better people , especially the original inhabitants .
            Shame about the greedy ones .

            Dee Mary and all writers readers at Gumshoe , Happy New Year !
            Keep on exposing the lies ! Love and peace to all .

      • aargh. Dee– an amazing post–end of a cycle-I was once told by a wise man–that Australia– has all of the “problems’ of the modern world– i.e. poverty drought racism corruption and inequality -etc etc It also has the solutions–Why–it is small enough -a microcosm within the macrocosm to set an examples/solutions- that others can follow.-Sounds sensible.
        Eddy -[please do not misinterpret -you give “me’ voice] sovereignty never ceded-Colonisation of lands and peoples-torture genocide murder theft -child abuse slavery–justified through education religion and psychiatry [medical-pharmacology-research experimentation]- I know about these things.
        Always was always will be aboriginal land–can the western mind include/embrace the cosmological world view within “its” expansive world view?–that of a different frequency that respond to the magnetic field/the understanding that everything is electricity-sound and light colour-electro -magnetic forces that embrace us- I know of these things.
        Federal state local government have it all stitched up–land theft identity theft –arrghh a class action about theft–
        and then I come to the tavistock agenda-the psychological warfare department-approved by Churchill-a buddy of Victor Rothschild-rupert-freud-the manipulation of the mind-aka mind control -operation paperclip-Bluebird -MKultra–Monarch programming.
        And Mary–you bring -amongst a wealth of “things” the MKultra US story-to the fore .
        I hold another part of that story –power to you/us all-may the force stay with us–
        Thank you Gumshoe News and all it stands for- to a powerful victorious 2018

  2. Australia has no ‘leaders’ for a sovereign debt free independent democratic country.
    They; being most, are just banker fascist running dogs for the fascist NWO.
    They are just gullible fools, the competent minority are prisoners of; their bureacrats, the treasonous msm and the fascist UN.
    One hope in 2018 depends on many waking up and GS is one of many arenas to demolish the running dog fake lying msm et.al., to awaken the sheeple.
    Best wishes to Dee and All for 2018.

  3. Thank you Dee and Mary

    Somehow this popped into mind re those “gullible fools” (and related Nedjictives)

    “To argue with a person who has denounced the use of reason is like administering medicine to the dead.”
    – Thomas Paine (1737-1809)

  4. Dee, please do more on the Amazon thing. It is weird up here in America how retail business merges with other things.

    For example, as you are checking out of a clothing shop, the clerk asks if you want to donate to hurricane relief. As you walk down the aisle of a supermarket you hear the loudspeaker say “People over 65 are at greater risk for pneumonia.” (So hop over to the pharmacy counter and get a free shot.) In Alabama I went to a casino on an Indian reservation that had a barber shop in it. (For men who spend all day at the pokies, I guess.)

    As you put things in your virtual cart at Amazon, they say “Name your favorite charity and we will send them your donation.” I see this as a way to separate the donor from the recipient. Oh God.

    Dee it’s your job to stop this in Federation Square.

    • Instead of the Apple mega store, I will vote for a row of pillories for those bureau-kleptocrats that have sold Oz down the river.
      But hang on,those people blocking their ears to PA, 7/7, 9-11, etc… maybe they deserve the store. Like moths to a flame.

      • No, they deserve pillories, too. Just for 10 minutes. Just for the experience of finding out that what they are doing is WRONG.

        Dee, Paul Craig Roberts said this in reviewing my Marathon book: “Any US citizen that believes the falsified case of the Boston Marathon bombing is a direct threat to the lives of millions of people on planet Earth.” So, too, Port Arthur.

  5. Dee and Mary,

    Congratulations on another fabulous year of chip, chip, chipping away at the sleeping masses Downunder. I am encouraged by the progress we are making. For 5 years I have tried to awaken a particular group of friends (an old guys soccer team) about chemtrails/geoengineering. While plainly visible in the sky back then(not so obvious today but still happening) hardly anyone could give a rats arse. Recently, the collective response changed from “bullshit, you’re crazy. As if the govt. would spray us” to “okay, we get that we’re being sprayed, but WHY are we being sprayed”. Is that progress? I guess so.

    Wait until they have to process the satanic ritual abuse issue. Oy vey!! Or that their government is a criminal, murderous enterprise. Or that deadly false flags, perpetuated by their own intelligence agencies are infested with child raping and killing pedophiles, as is the government itself. Or that just about everything they believe to be true is basically a massive lie. Or that vaccines are laced with harmful stuff. Or that the media lies blatantly about just about everything they report on.

    Having looked around Australia’s alternate media scene lately, (which I erroneously thought was almost non-existant) I see room for collaboration and “force-multiplying” between individual outlets. For example, here’s a list of contributors who do good work. They should collaborate and support each other and cause a cross pollination to gain further reach, otherwise it will take forever.

    Cairns News, Quadrant Online, The Crow House, Prepaussie (on Youtube), Michael Smith News,
    Mr Gunk (on Youtube), Independent Australia,(??-a bit left-biased but they having a go at “keeping the bastards honest”-and I mean bastards).

    Feel free to add to the list. Gumshoe could form a central registry of pissed off Aussies outlets.

    Have a fun New Year ‘s Eve tonight guys as we head onward into 2018, a year which should bring many amazing revelations.

  6. They have worked really hard to hide the geo engineering in the last year I notice.
    The cloud formations show the operation continues. I did also get a little traction on the possibility of a conspiracy when they are in full view. Not sure if fuel was changed or the program has gone to more dedicated high level overflight, but it continues daily.
    Phil, this is a kiwi site, uncensored.co.nz , they are choice bro.
    Happy full moon you crazy gummies.

  7. Reason is as useful, or as useless, as the information used to apply it. And as the information we are all forced to use whether mainstream or alternative is useless reason is therefore useless. The Age of Reason being another successful psyop as alerted by Brit pollie, Denis Healy when he said: world events do not occur by accident. They are made to happen, whether it is to do with national issues or commerce; and most of them are staged and managed by those with the purse strings.

    • Hey Mike,
      I’m not sure your meaning and you may be right, but given what we have to work with, we’ve got to start somewhere. And that is by joining the dots by investigation and using reason and logic (and commonsense) to work out what the hell is going on.

      I’m damned if I’m going to roll over and just cop this crap.

      Anyway, onwards and upwards into 2018. . Let’s see what else we can find out.

      Happy New Year-I hope..

  8. Sort of relevant to Phil’s discussion, although almost half century ago:
    In December 1971, Frank Serpico testified before the Knapp Commission:
    “Through my appearance here today… I hope that police officers in the future will not experience… the same frustration and anxiety that I was subjected to… for the past five years at the hands of my superiors… because of my attempt to report corruption. I was made to feel that I had burdened them with an unwanted task. The problem is that the atmosphere does not yet exist… in which an honest police officer can act… without fear of ridicule or reprisal from fellow officers. …

    “The most important result that can come from these hearings… is a conviction by police officers that the department will change. In order to ensure this… an independent, permanent investigative body… dealing with police corruption, like this commission, is essential….”

  9. My awakening has been in witnessing first-hand and in real time the atrocities and atrocity propaganda associated with the invasion of Syria. It has prompted me to look more broadly and to drill back in time to see when on earth this filth started.

    Hence it is with gratitude and appreciation to Dee and Mary for the Gumshoe site for helping me fast track this experience on many bewildering fronts – starting with the highly recommended “Truth in Journalism” publication.

    Probably the most significant success of this atrocity propaganda in the last century took me back to WWII (boy, was I surprised – I never knew just how big the red pill was!!) and I came across these words:

    • “Our language is not able to express the extent of our responsibility. This is more than a war, it is a battle for the world. A sinister conspiracy is attacking the foundations of human society. Whether humanity will be saved or whether it will collapse depends wholly on us. The enemy is using every possible base and cynical method to divert us from our mission, to tire us out, to weary our souls, to shake our hearts.”

    Same author (easy to find):

    • “There will come a day, when all the lies will collapse under their own weight and the truth will triumph again.”

    So far I am back about 3000-3500 years – same result and still digging.

    I am sure it predates ‘writing’ (say 5500 years ago) to the time the Homo sapiens (“wise man” *) species was able to “imagine” and delude itself verbally, and that writing systems just enabled us to solidify and propagate the myths as truths.

    [* “wise man” indeed – the original and ultimate oxymoron – surely we were misnamed and it should have been “Homo moros” !! – or is that where AI is leading us?]

    • I’ll go back to African LEGENDS,,, “Zulu Shaman, Credo Mutwa said that Zulu legends believe The Moon to be hollow and the home of hitauri. The Moon was brought here hundreds of generations ago by two brothers, Wowane and Mpanku, who were the leaders of these water brothers and they both had scaly skin like a fish. This tale is very similar to the Mesopotamia and Sumerian accounts about the two chief leader brothers Enlil and Enki, (Lords of the Earth). Wowane and Mpanku stole The Moon in the form of an egg from the “Great Fire Dragon,” and emptied out the yolk until it was hollow. Then they “rolled” The Moon across the sky to the Earth which brought about cataclysmic events on this planet that ended the “Golden Age” of the past.
      “Credo Mutwa claims that the Earth was very different then it is now before The Moon had arrived. There weren’t any seasons and the planet was perpetually engulfed by a canopy of water vapor. People did not feel the strong glare of the Sun that we do now, and they could only see it through a watery mist. The Earth was once a beautiful place, a lovely place, lush and green with giant Redwoods, Violets and Ferns with a gentle drizzle and mist. The water canopy fell to the Earth as a cataclysm of rain when The Moon was put into place in the Earth’s orbit. This is symbolized in the Bible when it rains for 40 days and 40 nights.
      Then… 1970, two Russian scientists, Mikhail Vasin and Alexander Shcherbakov,…
      (bedtime stories for 2017)

  10. Credo Mutwa? Now where have I heard his name before? David Icke talks about meeting Credo, and has alluded to the moon being an artificial, hollow structure. Damn, is nothing what we have been led to believe??

    CIA Director William Casey is quoted as saying in 1981-” “We’ll know our disinformation program is complete when everything the American public believes is false”

    Looks like they bloody well succeeded (almost). I now believe nothing coming from the Establishment.

  11. Interesting that you have started this post with sexual abuse and the supposed follow up and persuit of further cases.
    I’m struggling to understand, how this topic will be further examined, as I distinctly recall simila claims being made by the M.S.M. “Producer Claims Satanic Pedophile Ring Controls Hollywood”
    May 22, 2017
    Nwo Report https://nworeport.me/
    And this one ; Pizzagate Story.
    Note, the Pizzagate story was way back in FEBRUARY, yet where is the investigation today ?????
    Going by the M.S.M. it never happend, and it’s all good, nothing to see here folks.

    • George Carlin at 5:43: “… the police are on your side …”

      The following explains why this particular sector of grooming, rape gangs and paedophilia in Britain is not about to be reigned in any time soon …

      • Peter Whittle challenges Commissioner Cressida Dick on grooming gangs!
      • https://youtu.be/NOA9n3QdpFw

      Mx Dick (Police Commissioner) brushes off the concerns by stating that rape gang grooming has “been around for centuries and centuries” … implying that it is quite a NORMAL part of British society. Various commentators sarcastically ‘support’ that assertion by pointing out that that must be why this phenomenon is so prominently featured in the writings of Dickens, Shakespeare, Chaucer et al.

      Commissioner Dick will not like the fact that Donald Trump has just declared January 2018 as National Slavery and Human Trafficking Prevention Month.

      • https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/president-donald-j-trump-proclaims-january-2018-national-slavery-human-trafficking-prevention-month/

      “During National Slavery and Human Trafficking Prevention Month, we recommit ourselves to eradicating the evil of enslavement. Human trafficking is a modern form of the oldest and most barbaric type of exploitation. It has no place in our world. This month we do not simply reflect on this appalling reality. We also pledge to do all in our power to end the horrific practice of human trafficking that plagues innocent victims around the world.”

      “Human trafficking is a sickening crime at odds with our very humanity. An estimated 25 million people are currently victims of human trafficking for both sex and labor. Human traffickers prey on their victims by promising a life of hope and greater opportunity, while delivering only enslavement. Instead of delivering people to better lives, traffickers unjustifiably profit from the labor and toil of their victims, who they force — through violence and intimidation — to work in brothels and factories, on farms and fishing vessels, in private homes, and in countless industries.”

      On October 8, 2012, Trump tweeted:

      “Got to do something about these missing children grabbed by the perverts. Too many incidents – fast trial, death penalty.”

      [Let’s hope he is serious, genuine – and effective.]

    • Yep been here before, so can we agree if nothing happens, bout the pedo issue this year(18), we have been duped yet again.
      Hope to eat my words but…

  12. I was just catching up with the real news on Iran and had to share this from a post by AM Hants on the Duran article below. Just watch 30 seconds from 10:00 re war criminals John Howard/Stephen Harper scripted speech on Iraq.

    * https://youtu.be/eHDDQVZ-A98?t=600

    Informative articles:
    • Trump ramps us regime change rhetoric against Iran

    (key observation by commentators – all the ‘protest’ signs in this Farsi speaking country are in US-English for our western consumption. I am sure the ABC is having a field day.)

    • IRAN PROTEST CRISIS: Everything you need to know
    • http://www.fort-russ.com/2017/12/iran-protest-crisis-everything-you-need.html

  13. Ah yes, the Iran protest issue smells like yet another Color Revolution attempt by the Clowns In America. Surely the good folks in Iran remember Mohammed Mossadegh and Kermit Roosevelt (yeah, a distant one of those Roosevelts) and the Clowns toppling of a secular Iranian leader, just because he kicked out BP and their oil cartel mates?? Kermit even stated that it was a really cheap way to topple a government.
    Bring back the Shah and his secret police…….let the good times roll.

    I’d been wondering when they’d get around to Iran, as per Wes Clark’s famous media interview.

C'mon Leave a Reply, Debate and Add to the Discussion