[Editor’s Note: Gumshoe is grateful to Mark Wilhelm for alerting us to this letter which has been much reprinted. This version is slightly abridged and with bolding added.]
by Claudia von Werlhof*.
Copyright Claudia von Werlhof, Globalresearch.ca 2019
Dear Greta Thunberg,
You have not answered a 1st open letter at the beginning of your steep “career”, which has just culminated in the recognition of the Right Livelihood Award. I nevertheless write a 2nd one. I approached you with sympathy for your awakening and activism, looking at you like a kind of grandmother who would like to give you some advice – to a kind of granddaughter.
It was to give you better information about the real state of Mother Earth, because I noticed that you did not have this knowledge. This time I would rather address you in my quality as a scientist, which I am as well, as I hear that you seek the advice of science, for you seem to trust in your mind. This is good and it is really necessary.
However, there are always two kinds of science: one that is responsible for nothing less than the endangered state of Mother Earth herself, and one that is opposing it. I belong to the latter kind. That’s why I used to be an enthusiastic demonstrator and demonstration speaker and at first I was just happy how the youth everywhere reacted to your protest in masses.
Finally, a movement emerged and even for Mother Earth! Something more beautiful could not happen to me, especially because I was the founder of the “Planetary Movement for Mother Earth”….
[Y]ou have joined the assertion of international organizations, certain scientists of the first kind at the IPCC, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, as well as corporations, financial institutions, and people of the financial sector. They say that CO2 is the main, indeed the only problem of the planet, and its very low share of O.04% in the atmosphere (of which only a small part is manmade) is even the reason for a planetary “climate change” as a result….
In the name of an allegedly “green” New Deal, a “system change” against this “climate change” and its capitalist causes is now to be initiated. This … would consist of introducing a “sustainable lifestyle” in society, in which the consumption and use of particularly CO2-intensive products would be sharply reduced, or higher taxes would have to be paid. This should allegedly end “climate change” and “save” the earth….
What is wrong with that? Quite a lot:
— 1. Paradoxically, the planned system change by reducing energy consumption is undermined today by the plans for a massive development of the most energy-intensive high-tech dimensions in everyday life, which should lead to the digitization of all areas of life, the project of the corresponding “Smart Cities” and the installation of the necessary electromagnetic radiation at 5G level.
This way of dismantling, but at the same time also reconstructing and rebuilding industrial society, has already become a huge business in which trillions of dollars are at stake (1) and certainly not something “green” which is saving the earth!
Indeed, the 5G frequency requires the felling of many trees in the cities. So far the 5G-frequency has only been used in the military sector as it is a weapon that will even destroy life on Earth to an unknown extent, starting with insects, birds and babies in the womb and then going on with the elderly, where those in the middle will have to expect severe damages to their health (2).
So, the plans for what the “system change” that you want means, have been developed for some time already. They have nothing to do with the abolition of capitalism and are already being pushed through with full force from above.
Consequently, there are several simple questions that have to be answered:
Is it then a question of expanding nuclear energy in which the military is particularly interested? So, what kind of system change is this, what does it change about the “climate” which is a huge large-scale planetary system, and who gets pushed out?: The 5G victims, large regions of the South, the victims of radioactive contamination and…and and?
Why don’t you say anything about this “system change”, Greta?
— 2. It is just NOT true that CO2 threatens the earth. Yes, the earth would need at present even more CO2 for its plants and the life in general, because CO2 is an invisible plant gas and no dirt, which comes from chimneys, as is constantly suggested (3), about which however one does not talk at all.
CO2 is also not a greenhouse gas insofar as the earth is open to the sky and therefore not a greenhouse. The greenhouse effect cannot occur on a planet.
Yes, CO2 ensures that we have oxygen to breathe, because plants convert it into oxygen. So, if CO2 disappears as much as possible from the atmosphere, as you advocate, then we would end up going down by suffocating along with all life on the planet! Thus, there is something fundamentally wrong with the whole argumentation. It stands on feet of clay!
If you believe in science, as you always say, then you should not believe in the IPCC, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, because it is not a scientific, but a political organization. Thousands of scientists in the world have meanwhile spoken out against it (4), precisely because the IPCC claims that CO2 is to blame for this “climate change”.
The scientists who are not committed to the IPCC and its policies defend CO2, as I have just done. Others say that climate change can only result from a change in solar activity. But they cannot determine this for the times in question. The warming of the global average temperature claimed by the IPCC has not even occurred in the last 20 years, says the US space agency NASA.
How to interpret the weather changes that we are all observing
— 3. These changes are beyond question but should not be confused with the global climate system, which is long term and comprehensive.
The deliberate manipulation of the global climate would be a highly complex undertaking, is probably not possible at all, and certainly not through the use or reduction of a single plant gas like CO2. The global climate is simply of another dimension, incomparable to the local weather.
So the question is, where do these weather changes come from, be it in the form of droughts, floods, regional heat or cold waves, storms and severe weather systems that remain in place for a long time, the warming of the Arctic that is significantly above all other temperature changes (at least until 2012), the alleged “forest” fires in California, Australia and Portugal, which destroyed houses to their foundations and melted cars, but left the trees around them mostly intact (5), not to mention the catastrophic jungle fires in the Amazon, Africa and South Asia that are clearly caused by human intervention.
Also the massive extinction of animals and plants, e.g. insects, birds, corals and trees as well as the otherwise rapidly increasing loss of species can in no way be explained by CO2! That is completely impossible and simply nonsense.
The same applies to the pollution of the air, the soil and the water with not only fine dust, but a nano fine dust of aluminum, strontium, barium, lithium, polymers, coal ash, genetically modified substances, bacteria and many other substances penetrating all organs up to the brain, which have been proven for two and more decades now, among other things by the application of aerosols in the atmosphere, above all in the northern hemisphere.
The method of spraying aerosols has a scientific name, it is called SRM, Solar Radiation Management, and is recommended for allegedly blocking solar radiation in favor of lower temperatures on Earth – but in reality it has long been used for quite different purposes, in any case for those that harm all life on Earth up to its extinction and cause many diseases of epidemic proportions (6).
And finally, contrary to forecasts, in recent years the ozone layer in the atmosphere has been increasingly destroyed, which has led to harmful UV radiation now reaching the earth unfiltered everywhere in the northern hemisphere and threatening microorganisms in particular. The food chain on land and in the oceans has already been attacked and corals are “starving” (7).
So if something doesn’t happen soon to strengthen the ozone layer permanently, i.e. over the next decades, which includes knowing and admitting what it really suffers from – and this is certainly not only the civilian CFC that is supposedly responsible for it, and CO2 has nothing to do with it at all – then we could soon be threatened ourselves, because agriculture can suddenly break down by being permanently exposed to toxic UV-B- and C- radiation.
However, the ozone layer cannot be strengthened by artificially introducing ozone into the stratosphere, but only by ceasing to affect this thin, but absolutely vital layer – as it is, in reality, affected by radioactivity, the heating of the ionosphere, microwaves, air traffic, rocket fuels and supersonic flights, for instance.
The many wars in the world and the irreversible consequences of the widespread use of depleted uranium, a waste material from nuclear plants, for example, are not even mentioned here (8).
You see, you have been denied crucial information about the real situation of the planet, its dangers and their causes, explaining everything with CO2, no matter what it was, and you have simply believed it. To this day, however, you are on your way claiming to have understood the core of the matter and having to present what seems to follow from it.
I also understand that at 16 you can’t know everything. But what you and the others need to know if you really want to be a movement conscious of your responsibility for Mother Earth and not against her, that knowledge exists! So get it if you are serious about your movement. Otherwise,
[Y]our credibility will soon be inevitably gone (9)….
— 4. The knowledge unknown to you came about above all because Dr. Rosalie Bertell, whom I recommended to you in my first letter already and who also received the RLA, the Right Livelihood Award, 33 years ago. She worked as a biometrician and environmental scientist for the UN on the history of military technologies in the East and the West since the Second World War.
These technologies are the key to answering the question of what is happening or can be done today to make it happen. She [Bertell] mentions especially the damage caused by nuclear interventions, for example the explosion of more than two thousand atomic and hydrogen bombs (!) in the atmosphere and on Earth, which occurred during half a century. She goes on with explaining post-nuclear technologies. These are those used for “weather wars, plasma weapons and military geoengineering”, invented during the last 70 years based on the discovery of how to use electromagnetic waves.
This technology was developed by the physicist Nikola Tesla and is now increasingly practiced everywhere on the planet, for example by a growing number of installations of the so-called “ionosphere heaters” [HAARP]. However, all this is not publicly admitted!
But it is happening, as can be read in the so-called ENMOD Convention of the UN, 1977, the Environmental Modification Convention, or in the report “Weather as a Force Multiplier – Owning the Weather in 2025” of the US Air Force, published in 1996.
These technologies have already been discussed twice in the European Parliament, in 1999 and 2013, until the EU Commission banned the EP from dealing with them further in 2016, because they are military questions (!).
The military activities that were and are concealed from the public, explain everything we observe in reality and what is generally referred to as “climate change”. This is the result of decades of war against the earth and its transformation into a literal “weapon of war” of the military in the East and the West.
Rosalie Bertell, who came to Germany from the USA in 2010, not long before her death, assisting the 30th anniversary of the Right Livelihood Award, therefore called for a discussion on the topic among her colleagues, who were also award-winners, shouting:
“It is not CO2! It is the military!”
And she hung out a petition, which was signed by all those present. It reads: “It is morally reprehensible and a declaration of war on mankind and the earth to intervene in the normal functioning of the planetary order by causing or intensifying storms, hurricanes, tsunamis, monsoons, landslides, droughts, floods, earthquakes or volcanic eruptions!”
So, if you and your movement … want to approach the truth and do what Mother Earth needs now, namely our solidarity because of what is done to her all the time, then take care that you know what it is all about and fight against it. For that is what determines our future, and not CO2, which belongs to nature and which you instead portray as its enemy!
… These interests are the ones that finance and organize everything worldwide on a large scale: Your weekly Fridays for Future-Demos, the “doomsday parties” as I call them, together with the “Die-ins”, … don’t you realize what a perversion this is? They are the ones who produce and provide your regional offices worldwide, who organize the big spectacles, for example with famous pianists, the movies, videos, media work, propaganda material and all that –
[D]o they do it, because they like you so much?
— 5. These interests … need you to draw the youth and especially the women to their side! For women have always addressed the subject of nature and ecology more than men…. This is now being exploited by you being the ones to represent the new plans and interests of big Capital, to promote them and to ensure the implementation of their goals.
It is you who are supposed to propagate a kind of “cultural revolution” so that … an additional business model can be built up, and the new start of the system can take place profitably … of course leaving behind a pile of shattered remains in the form of the “old” society, which must first be smashed and destroyed!
How else could that work, namely without you, and thus without provoking the uprising – and this time one for a truly anti-capitalist society for all? So, your role is to spare them such a true upheaval! Why are you helping them?
It is wonderful that the young people are enthusiastic about Mother Earth. I have waited a long time for this to occur. But strangely enough, what you are doing now is not a blessing for Mother Earth, but her mockery! What you have done so far is the reverse of what is needed….
So, don´t let yourself be abused any longer for the opposite of what you want to stand up for, by people who have everything but the good of Mother Earth in mind, and even work on her destruction! … The clock is ticking, but not for the reduction of CO2!
Conclusion: … [Y]ou have distracted attention from the destructions that have been increasingly perpetrated on the earth for decades and that are being added to those already known, being the ones committed by the military – on the ground, in the water and in the air, and more recently also from space. This way you are preventing the … massive dangers for life on earth and the earth herself from finally being seen, recognized and answered at all.
You’re doing Earth a disservice. But there is still time to turn around and understand and address the real problems instead of the fake ones!
I fear, however, that “they” will not allow it.
[Signed] Prof. Dr. Claudia von Werlhof, Planetary Movement for Mother Earth, Austria
A good article on the recent ‘demands’ of the Grim Greta. Read the comments to the article. Crikey, this poor kid needs some adult help outside the people that are manipulating her. Sad, really sad that an environmental movement could collapse to this kind of insanity.
https://www.sott.net/article/424991-Ahead-of-COP25-Child-Climate-Goddess-Greta-Demands-Complete-Dismantling-of-Colonial-Racist-Patriarchal-Systems-of-Oppression
“You have stolen my dreams and my childhood with your empty words”
What “empty words” exactly ?
“People are suffering; people are dying”
Which is, of course, part & parcel of life itself.
The entire mantra is just one more reminder that resentment and self-pity are the most toxic and destructive forces on the face of the earth
What a great article?
This 16 year old has been used very well by the EVIL ones. It would be interesting to know how much she or her family have or are being paid, for this criminal non-educational enterprise.
For a young person who repeatedly mentions science, she seems to be lacking in the basic understanding of high school science. Unless the schooling system is deliberately withholding the information that I was taught, from today’s students.
I would not be surprised, as I was given some information this last week about the happenings of a particular primary school. The teachers seem to be without knowledge of how to organise anything.
An art competition was organised by an organisation that I am involved with. The children entered some very good work. However the teachers allowed the students to place their nick names on their endeavours. When it came time to issue the awards, the teachers could not provide the appropriate names of those winners. Remarkable!
Great news, Mal– (recalling a news item on the radio this morning) – Australia has recorded its lowest ever ranking for students in mathematics, reading and science, while teens from China’s wealthiest regions rank top of the class in global education survey.. We should be comforted by the minister’s expression of ‘concern’. I would say everything is going along just fine according to plan. And we wonder why there is a ‘threat’!
This is somewhat related – especially the opening passages (extracts as follows)
Our Subverted History, – The Germanic Peoples
“A trait that acts as a great strength in homogenous environments creating high trust atmospheres in which justice and the nobler instincts can flourish can act as an *equally great disadvantage in instances in which peoples and cultures mix indiscriminately** – and begin to act in their own tribal interests, often covertly. The Goths were to commit the civilisation-destroying blunder of the trusting assumption that others were wired similarly to themselves – or held to the same standards and possessed a similar worldview.
It is an unfortunate historical reality that the unethical and amoral man is nowhere more powerful and efficient than within a virtuous and just society. While those around him restrain their vices and through strength and discipline keep their baser nature in subservient check, he has no such qualms and thus his playbook is vastly larger with virtually nothing being off limits.“
In the same news bulletin this morning, the intrepid Ms Thunberg has just arrived in Lisbon following a three week journey on the “family yacht”.
According to Henry Makow:
“The €4 million yacht on which Greta sailed to the USA, was a yacht of the Rothschild family, who transferred it to German tycoon Gerhard Senft. Co-captaining the voyage was Pierre Casiraghi, grandson of Monaco’s late Prince Rainier III and actress Grace Kelly.”
https://www.henrymakow.com/2019/09/Greta-Thunberg-Rothschild-Pawn.html
What interests me re the war against fossil fuels is that, in a Country such as Australia that has more than enough sun-power to drive everything, the respective apparatus is well beyond the means of Mr.& Ms. Average and none of the Climate groupies have come up with any sort of solution
Totally mind blowing article, should be diseminated far and wide. Amazing that this woman makes the connections with the Military and the flow effects of their tampering. I’m a bit disappointed though, that the connection of the Atmospheric Nuclear explosions and the effect these had on the Ozone layer are not dealt with, only glossed over. I don’t believe for a micro second, that Greta’s handlers would ever allow her to see this correspondence ever.
Great article. And thank you Terry for another great SOTT link – and for yesterday’s on the 3600-year Comet Cycle. I am still wading through Pierre Lescaudron’s earlier articles starting with the mammoths as well as chasing down Richard Carrier’s “Historicity”. That 13,000-odd year timeframe re a likely catastrophic extinction event just keeps cropping up.
Sometimes we need to lighten up to get the message across …
A Letter from a Constituent About How He Advised His Teenage Daughter on ‘Climate Change’
https://www.armstrongeconomics.com/world-news/climate/letter-how-to-advise-a-teenage-daughter-on-climate-change/
See more articles at link “Categories: Climate” including The Killing Fields & Greenpeace’s Greta Thunberg which details who is funding Greta and the close association of her narrative with that of Pol Pot.
I keep coming back to the words I have cited previously by Alexander Dugin:
“When we read scientific literature written in the 70s [] we’re immersed in a world of openly honest people. They can be mistaken [] but they are all genuinely dedicated to the logos. And then there’s some kind of frontier, when they all started to lie …“
I found out about the 3,600 comet cycle about 20 years ago. Thought about it and decided there was nothing I could do to mitigate the threat. If you’re in the impact zone, you’re a gonner. Which may be why the ultra rich have multiple bug-out properties around the world – and a private aircraft to get there.
If this cycle is anything like 12,900 years ago, then it will be an extinction level event. Hopefully, it will just be a little dust up like the last one.
The Grand Solar Minimum on the other hand is something that can be mitigated against. Unfortunately, most people remain oblivious to the issue and considering the amount of MSM coverage of something like ‘Greta’, I don’t believe that is an accident.
Chilly (again) today, and this article and the comments so far prompted me to watch something a little more relaxing – and inspiring – no, not the Adani coal mine in the Great Barrier Reef hinterland.
How China transformed its desert into a fruit growing oasis
In pursuit of green development — China’s Green Dream
Speaking of lakes (*watch this one first)
**Precious Necklace of Baikal
“The lake [Baikal] contains 20% of the world’s fresh water resources”
That Trans-Siberian rail journey is looking awfully inviting.
Nature is certainly a big, glorious place.
Hi everyone, i have been busy over the past year or more researching and testing new knowledge gained about the use and power of words in this fictional world we find ourselves in… I have much to share on grammar, flags and stamps. Plus i have continued to research any and all topics that have been shown to me in many ways as part of my journey. I will share my research with this website as often as possible and hope to create some original articles based on my successes in using and testing some of the knowledge i have gained.
Sounds like a plan.
“the use and power of words”
As in paragraph 3 of the article where the word “science” is used instead of “technology”?
Prof. von Werlhof states that : ‘ Thousands of scientists in the world have meanwhile spoken out against it [ Anthropogenic Global Warming / Climate Change ] .
Refer to the following video & see if her claim has any validity :
As a matter of fact, there were (in 2014 when the video was made ) , tens of thousands of scientists that signed a petition against Climate Change alarmism.
Now, 5 years later, the petition has many 1000’s more.
Let's turn our attention to WindTurbines & see how they're faring in the video below :
Hmmm ….. it seem like the higher order birds of prey with their larger wingspans aren’t faring so well with Green renewable energy initiatives.
Yes Greta Thunberg, I’m with you when you point fingers & say : ‘ How dare you ‘ .
(Only those fingers should be directed at the criminal cabal that foisted this Climate-hoax on our children & child-like adults with under-developed critical thinking capabilities ) .
1 December 2019 This shows how the rain is blocked coming into Australia
‘Weather Modification, geoengineering, solar radiation management’
Good rain headed for Land, gone before it gets here ‘
55 Towers in Australia.
I recall reports of strange radar signals about ten years ago that appear now more numerous. They claimed they were radar glitches!
It would appear that we are in a undeclared war and our enemy is running a fifth column of media and political running dogs and traitors in our midst.
TRAITORS !!!!
Agenda 21 sustainable development is the
comprehensive plan of action for global communist world government.
The fires are intentional, to force people off the land and herd everyone into the cities for a 5G surveillance credit points system gulag.
Environmental (geo engineering man made) disasters will force, upon our mass, one dystopian dictatorship.
Drive through Chatswoo, and you will see Bentley Maserati Porsche SUV’S, many with green P plates, ubiquitously surrounding the streetscape.
It’s not a matter of if or when, we are here now.
Oz a CCP colony and everything mainstream is
bull…………!
von Werlhof is a 76 year old sociology/Women’s Studies professor from Germany, a co-founder with Maria Mies of eco-feminism. There is a lengthy entry on her in German in Wikipedia and the Talk page there shows what her controversies have been; there is no entry on her in English.
It is disingenuous to stress her professorial title as if she were a natural scientist on a par with climatologists.
I note that her mode of arguing is not that of natural science but of political observation and allegation and insinuation.
Note also that Prof em. Guy McPherson, doyen
https://guymcpherson.com/
of the Doomer community, is a natural scientist by training (biologist), unlike von Werlhof.
So when he says there is no evidence for HAARP, I tend to believe him more than I do her, as also on the topic of C02.
Duns Scotus,
What’s your view on Exmouth Pine Gap and chemtrails really being contrails?
Guy sounds like Greta’s tutor.
You don’t need a doctorate or degree to be observant, might even be counter productive.
As a kid we used to put iron fillings on paper, then place and move a magnet underneath. Depending on “angles of attack” the fillings could be manipulated into various patterns.
I have observed on hundreds of occasions the dumping of “matter” from jet aircraft. Often these operations are followed by patterns similar to the iron filling experience.
However you must be both observent and outside to witness the unnatural formations.
Cinematographers must know if the need a good old fashion blue sky.
It’s not her lack of government approval(creds) that makes me wary but rather the “mother earth” cant.
As nature worship rules out any sort of creative and constructive use of natural resources it’s just the flip-side of exploitative engineering
The Gulag that will be finalised in Australia.
It was tested in Norfolk Island in about 2010.
Just search;
‘Norfolk Island carbon living test”
I just have and a report first up is from the SMH;
‘ISLANDERS LEAD WORLD ON PERSONAL CARBON TEST SCHEME’.
Basicaly, the citzens get a credit card and deductions are made for every use of a bit of Co2…. eg, if they buy petrol or eat stuff considered unhealthy.
This concept was foreshadowed by Dr Day in March 1969, as reported by Dr Dunegan.
Just search here at gumshoe or ‘NWO exposed by insider in 1969’. It comes up at jeffrense.com.
WAKE UP. …….. at least for your kids and TELL THEM WHAT THE BANKER FASCISTS AND CORPORATE GREEDY CONTROL FREAKS ARE IMPLMENTING. ……… IT IS CALLED FEUDALISM AND SLAVERY!
THE FAKE MSM HAS DECLARED WAR AGAINST ALL AUSTRALIANS, OUR DEMOCRACY, FREEDOM AND SOVEREIGNTY. TRAITORS.
Weather As A Force Multiplier: Owning The Weather In 2025….
“1996 USAF paper about weather modification: “The purpose of this paper is to outline a strategy for the use of a future weather modification system to achieve military objectives rather than to provide a detailed technical road map.”
Popular among conspiracy theorists”
https://archive.org/details/WeatherAsAForceMultiplier
conspiracy theorists like … ??
DoD News Briefing: Secretary of Defense William S. Cohen
Presenter: Secretary of Defense William S. Cohen
April 28, 1997 8:45 AM EDT
“and others are designing some sort of engineering, some sort of insects that can destroy specific crops. Others are engaging even in an eco- type of terrorism whereby they can alter the climate, set off earthquakes, volcanoes remotely through the use of electromagnetic waves. ”
https://archive.defense.gov/Transcripts/Transcript.aspx?TranscriptID=674